Stefania Romenti and Grazia Murtarelli


Listening as an Organisational Choice: From Stakeholder Signals to Relational Governance

Stefania Romenti, PhD, is Full Professor in Strategic Communication and Public Relations at IULM University, Milan. She serves as Pro-Rector for Educational Affairs, Director of the PhD Program in Communication, Markets and Society, and Director of the Research Center in Strategic Communication (CECOMS) at IULM University. She is also Director of the Executive Master in Corporate Public Relations. She is Past President of the European Public Relations Education and Research Association (EUPRERA). She has published two monographs, eleven edited volumes, and numerous articles in leading international journals, including the Journal of Business Ethics, MIT Sloan Management Review, Journal of Business Research, International Journal of Strategic Communication, and Public Relations Review. Her research focuses on strategic communication, corporate social responsibility communication, measurement and evaluation, stakeholder engagement, and sustainability communication.


Grazia Murtarelli, PhD, is Associate Professor of Strategic Communication at IULM University, Milan, where she teaches in undergraduate, master’s and doctoral programmes in corporate communication, public relations and strategic communication. She serves as Coordinator of the Master of Science in Strategic Communication and is a member of the Research Center in Strategic Communication (CECOMS) at IULM University. She is also a member of the PhD faculty board of the PhD Program in Communication, Markets and Society. Her research focuses on corporate public relations and strategic communication, with particular attention to digital communication, digital transformation, online dialogue, stakeholder engagement, and the measurement and evaluation of digital communication activities.


Listening as an Organisational Choice: From Stakeholder Signals to Relational Governance

Abstract
This paper revisits organisational listening through the relational perspective developed in Toni Muzi Falconi’s contribution to public relations and strategic communication. It argues that listening should be understood as a core infrastructure of relational governance, rather than as a marginal communication practice or a merely technical activity of environmental monitoring. Organizations in the present digital environment have access to many signals that emanate from their stakeholders. However, while organizations may have access to a lot of information about their stakeholders, they are not necessarily good listeners in relation to their stakeholders’ issues. Listening in the organizational context takes on meaning when the organization uses information to develop insights that lead to action. To this end, this paper presents a theoretical framework for organisational listening that is defined by three closely intertwined components, namely signal detection, interpretive sensemaking, and organisational responsiveness. The discussion of the relationship between the dimensions of listening presented above is expected to contribute to the literature on listening by placing it in the context of stakeholder governance, organisational adaptation, and communicative legitimacy. Additionally, the analysis presented in this paper can be of particular interest to practitioners in public relations and other related fields.
 
Keywords: organisational listening, relational governance, stakeholder relationships, public relations, legitimacy, strategic communication, Toni Muzi Falconi
 

Introduction

Listening has been recognised as an essential part of the process of communication in public relations and strategic communication for quite some time now. According to the relational paradigm underlying the discipline, organisations are social and institutional actors whose legitimacy depends on their capacity to establish and nurture meaningful relationships with the various social environments to which they belong. From this perspective, listening cannot be regarded as a preliminary activity that precedes communication or as an instrument to collect stakeholder opinions. Rather, it is one of the tools organisations use to acknowledge interdependence, interpret expectations and engage in relationships that are crucial to governance.

These ideas have their roots in several decades of academic research on public relations and relational communication. The excellence paradigm stressed the importance of two-way symmetrical communication for building better and more responsible relationships between organisations and publics (Grunig, 1992). More recent relational approaches have helped to clarify that organisation-public relationships represent one of the primary dimensions of public relations, not a secondary effect of communication activity (Ledingham, 2003). Finally, dialogic perspectives highlighted the importance of creating opportunities for mutual recognition, openness and responsiveness in order for communication to acquire real value (Kent & Taylor, 2002). Against this backdrop, listening can be understood as a key prerequisite for relational communication.

In this regard, the contributions of Toni Muzi Falconi deserve particular attention. Throughout his career, he has consistently argued in favour of conceptualising public relations as a management function built upon relationships, organisational responsibility and governance of interdependence. From this perspective, listening goes beyond the mere activities of consultation and opinion collection. Indeed, it deals with the capacity and willingness of the organisation to incorporate stakeholder expectations into processes of decision making. In other words, it can be regarded as an indication of the organisation’s relational maturity and shows whether publics are considered as audiences, as sources of risk or as interlocutors whose expectations can influence organisational behaviour.

This aspect is all the more significant in the present communication environment. Organisations are flooded with information on their stakeholders, publics, communities, employees, consumers, institutional actors and others. However, listening is not necessarily the outcome of such abundance of information. As pointed out by Macnamara, organisations are increasingly investing in speaking, visibility and message dissemination but are paying less attention to ensuring that the publics’ voices are actually heard (Macnamara, 2016). Listening involves far more than simply being exposed to stakeholder expressions; it also encompasses selecting and interpreting stakeholder messages and incorporating them within organisational practices.

The key issue here does not concern whether organisations are capable of collecting relevant information on their stakeholders. Instead, the critical question relates to whether or not they are willing to give meaning and significance to what they have listened to. Stakeholder theory has long been demonstrating that organisations operate in a network of claims, expectations and responsibilities extending beyond shareholders’ interests (Freeman, 1984). Furthermore, legitimacy research has shown that the legitimacy of organisations depends on the perception of their activities as being appropriate in the larger system of norms, values and beliefs (Suchman, 1995). Listening takes place precisely at the junction between these two aspects.

Listening enables organisations to understand stakeholders’ evolving expectations and detect potential areas of conflict. Above all, it allows the organisations to become aware of how their activities are being perceived in a larger social setting. In these terms, listening can be conceptualised as a strategic choice made by organisations to interpret their social environment and adapt to it. This perspective invites us to move beyond the consideration of listening as a technical tool and look at it as an organisational practice that contributes to negotiating legitimacy and accountability.

This paper seeks to develop this approach to listening in public relations by putting forward a framework based on three key dimensions of organisational listening: the recognition of stakeholder expectations, relational interpretation and organisational responsiveness.
 
Listening and the Relational Tradition in Public Relations

According to the relational paradigm of public relations, organisations are actors whose legitimacy and reputation depend, among other things, on their capacity to establish credible and socially responsible relationships with their stakeholders. From this point of view, public relations cannot be conceived as a function dedicated to visibility and message distribution, as much as it involves the ability of organisations to interpret their interdependencies, expectations and relationships. The concept fits well into the development of relationship management as the most popular theoretical framework for public relations studies (Ledingham, 2003; Ledingham & Bruning, 1998).

Toni Muzi Falconi’s contributions can be viewed in the context of this intellectual tradition, but his view also adds a specific managerial dimension to it. According to Muzi Falconi, public relations play a key role in shaping organisational governance by making the organisation sensitive to the expectations of stakeholders. In this way, public relations are not just an auxiliary function for communication management, image building or consensus creation. They are a managerial function that helps the organisation interpret its interdependencies and act more responsibly towards stakeholders.

Listening is fundamental for this understanding of public relations. If relationships are relational, dynamic and socially constituted, then the organisation must rely on systematic tools that allow it to grasp their implications. Listening is one of such tools, because it helps the organisation understand the relational meaning of its actions and detect possible mismatches between intended communication and stakeholder perceptions. At the same time, this is true also for dialogic approaches to public relations. Listening is a necessary condition for creating the kind of mutual relationship that characterises dialogue. Therefore, listening is not a secondary component of communication management. It is a constitutive element of relational public relations.

This conception of listening also distinguishes it from opinion gathering practices. Listening activities are certainly supported by a variety of methods, including surveys, interviews, consultation processes, media analysis and even digital monitoring of stakeholders’ conversations. However, this material becomes truly useful only when it is interpreted, debated and linked to organisational actions. As noted by Macnamara (2016), organisations devote significant resources to communication and visibility, while institutional listening tends to be relatively neglected. Listening is, therefore, not just a methodological problem. It is an organisational status that is attributed to the information collected from stakeholders.

From a relational perspective, listening implies the recognition of the interpretative potential of stakeholder voices. Of course, this does not mean that the organisation needs to respond to all stakeholder demands and comply with all their claims. There are indeed many differences among stakeholders and many conflicts between their perspectives. However, listening implies that such perspectives will not be disregarded or simply considered as a threat to the organisation’s image. They will be taken into account as meaningful reflections of the position of the organisation within its relational environment. This is the part of the more general process of seeking organisational legitimacy and social acceptance (Suchman, 1995).

The idea of listening from a relational perspective is closely connected to stakeholder theory. Indeed, Freeman’s (1984) seminal contribution introduced the idea of considering organisations as embedded within complex and dynamic networks of actors who are capable of impacting or being impacted by organisational decisions. This view contrasts with the traditional managerial paradigm and encourages organisations to acknowledge the multiplicity of claims that surrounds them. Listening becomes an important mechanism for doing so and engaging actively with stakeholders’ claims and perspectives.

It is important to note here the idea of organisational choice regarding listening. Organisations are free to choose which stakeholder claims and perspectives they will take into account in their decision-making process, even to the extent of ignoring them or considering them as irrelevant. On the contrary, organisations can create listening systems to discuss and debate stakeholder perspectives and use them for decision making. This shows the importance of institutions and organisational culture in making listening effective or not. Thus, listening is a question of organisational governance.

As we have seen, a relational approach to listening reveals the fact that listening implies a specific organisational status that goes beyond mere communication. It becomes a critical test of the relational capabilities of public relations. Listening shows whether the organisation understands publics as passive receivers, persuasive targets or relational partners whose perspectives can add value to organisational actions. This is the reason why Muzi Falconi’s relational view of public relations retains its topicality and importance today.
 
The Multiplication of Stakeholder Signals

The context for organisational listening has been transformed over the last decades in several respects. Stakeholder expressions now take place across a much broader array of arenas, publics and forms of involvement than in the past. Employees, customers, citizens, shareholders, regulatory agencies, activism groups and neighbouring communities all have different roles in the social interpretation of organisational conduct. Such expressions might happen in the course of formal consultations, institutional dialogues, debates in the media, discussions in the workplace, customer feedback, public controversies or general public discourse. Thus, the exposure of organisations to social interpretations has taken a much more fragmented and constant form.

However, this phenomenon cannot be reduced to a purely technological factor. Although digital environments have played a significant part in the increased visibility, speed and traceability of stakeholder expressions, the issue at stake lies much further down the organisational and relational spectrum. In the contemporary setting, organisations are placed in communicative environments where their conduct is subject to constant interpretation by a range of social publics who often act outside organisational settings. This development is consonant with the basic tenet of stakeholder theory: organisations operate in networks of actors, whose expectations, resources and judgement can influence organisational legitimacy and strategic effectiveness (Freeman, 1984; Mitchell, Agle, & Wood, 1997).

The diversification of stakeholder expressions represents both a challenge and an opportunity for organisational listening. On the one hand, organisations gain access to greater, diversified and rich information about the perceptions of their actions and behaviour. They can identify emerging tensions, discover new challenges, and uncover the sources of misalignment between their actions and social judgements. On the other hand, the abundance of stakeholder expressions can lead to dispersion, selectivity and information overload. There is a high probability that the organisations will react only to those issues and expressions that have already gained visibility or power, ignoring others that may represent the source of organisational weakness and relational vulnerability.

This differentiation between visibility and importance of stakeholder expressions is crucial for organisational listening. While visible public controversies require immediate attention and reaction, they are not the only issues that deserve such treatment. Persistent albeit minor concerns, mild discontent, internal disagreement or marginalised stakeholder opinions might serve as the indication of potential legitimacy problems. Thus, organisational listening implies judgement. It means that the organisation must be able to discriminate between the noise and the signal, between sporadic critique and the emergence of the problem, between public turmoil and actual relational misalignments.

To a large extent, organisational listening has close ties to organisational sensemaking. Stakeholder expressions by themselves do not convey any organisational meaning, but they acquire this quality in light of the specific situation, background, expectations and consequences associated with particular stakeholder opinions. Weick’s concept of sensemaking seems to be helpful here since it suggests that organisations do not merely process the information, but make sense of it under the conditions of uncertainty (Weick, 1995). Organisational listening is the essential aspect of this process. It enables organisations to understand the meaning of stakeholder expressions in terms of the current social position of the organisation and the validity of their actions.

Time pressure also adds to the challenge faced by organisations. It is quite common for organisations to be expected to react to stakeholder opinions in a very short period of time, especially in case they have attracted public attention. At the same time, such time constraints can come into conflict with the necessity of proper interpretation. In a number of cases, a timely reaction to stakeholder opinions requires promptness and agility of the organisation, but too hasty interpretation of the issue may result in defence mechanisms, knee-jerk reactions and superficial judgments. In turn, the delayed reaction to the opinion might create the impression that the organisation ignores this stakeholder voice. Therefore, organisational listening must be accompanied by organisational reflexion, i.e. the ability to respond immediately to emerging concerns while still maintaining the interpretative process.

The work of professional communicators has a prominent place in this process of sensemaking and interpretation. Communicators should not only observe stakeholder expressions and report them back to the management. They are expected to support the organisation in interpreting these expressions in the relevant context, linking them to the organisational relational dynamics and making sure that they are addressed in decision-making processes. In this sense, organisational listening is not a peripheral communicative task. It plays a major role in enabling organisational awareness of its interdependencies and proper governance of relationships with various publics.
Thus, it should be concluded that the abundance of stakeholder expressions in the contemporary environment does not necessarily contribute to organisational listening. In fact, there is a certain danger of information overload in this regard. Listening becomes effective only if organisations are capable of translating dispersed stakeholder expressions into organisational sensemaking. It follows that in spite of increased complexity of stakeholder communication today, organisational listening must maintain its fundamental quality as relational governance practice.
 

A Three Dimensional Framework of Organisational Listening

Understanding listening as an aspect of relational governance entails seeing it neither as a particular organizational activity nor as a methodological instrument. On the contrary, listening should be regarded as an organization’s relational capability that allows identifying stakeholder expressions, interpreting them and, whenever needed, integrating them with the organisational agenda. This perspective enables moving away from a procedural view of listening towards recognizing its impact on public relations, organisational legitimacy and organizational responsibility.

The suggested framework rests on three dimensions which complement each other – the recognition of stakeholder concerns, relational interpretation and organisational responsiveness. Though analytically distinct, those dimensions are intertwined and depend on one another. Without interpretation, recognition brings about an accumulation of information. Without responsiveness, interpretation leads to awareness without consequences. Uninterpreted responsiveness entails a reactive or purely symbolic adjustment. Organizational listening implies combining the three mentioned above elements.

The first element – recognition of stakeholder concerns – means that an organisation recognizes the expectations, claims, tension, and evaluation stemming from its interactions with stakeholders. This recognition could take place during consultation processes, stakeholder engagement activities, employee feedback, media monitoring, debates, community interactions or other types of interactions between the organisation and its surroundings. What really matters is the ability of an organisation to listen to stakeholders’ experiences and judgement. The important thing is that listening involves not just hearing something, but attending to someone.

Recognition of stakeholder concerns is closely linked to the insights developed in stakeholder theory. According to Freeman (1984), an organisation exists and operates in a network of actors, some of whom are capable of affecting the company’s actions or getting affected by them. However, the identification of stakeholder concerns is not enough; it is equally important to determine their relevance. Mitchell, Agle and Wood’s (1997) discussion of the salience of stakeholders can be helpful in this regard. Attention to stakeholders depends not only on the recognition of their existence but also on perception of their power and legitimacy. Moreover, stakeholder concerns are always related to urgent issues. That is why a relational view of listening should not ignore the risks of biased and incomplete recognition of stakeholders’ voices. Powerful and prominent stakeholders are not the only ones whose voices matter.

The second element – relational interpretation – means the interpretation of stakeholder concerns within the organisational context. Concerns of stakeholders should be understood as information. However, to become organisational knowledge, the information needs to be put into the organisational context and interpreted with respect to organisational past, identity, intentions, values and social expectations. As Weick (1995) argues, organisations live in ambiguous contexts and create meanings through interpretation. Listening contributes to organizational interpretation by encouraging organisations to challenge their assumptions and learn about the meaning of organisational actions in a relational environment.

Interpretation is especially critical when concerns of stakeholders expose gaps between organisational intentions and experiences of those stakeholders. An organization may justify a decision in terms of coherence with its strategic goals, whereas stakeholders will perceive the same action as contradictory to the organisation’s values or earlier promises. Listening brings organisations to face such gaps or inconsistencies, which are often quite uncomfortable for organisations but extremely valuable in terms of organisational strategy. Organisations need to be aware of such inconsistencies before they turn into major legitimacy problems.

Though communication specialists have much to do to collect and interpret stakeholder concerns, their meaning may involve other organisational spheres. Stakeholder knowledge may relate to various spheres – employees, environmental and sustainability issues, service provision, corporate social responsibility, public affairs, community relations, etc. Listening turns into an organizational practice once stakeholder knowledge gets beyond the limits of the communication department and becomes accessible within the management sphere.

Organizational responsiveness means that listening brings consequences for the organisational agenda. Responsiveness separates consequential listening from symbolic listening. An organization may receive feedback, acknowledge stakeholder concerns, report on the results, but leave its assumptions, decisions, actions unchanged. Symbolic listening, which lacks responsiveness, is a risky practice because organisations may appear to be hypocritical and deceptive. Responsiveness implies that listening organizations use stakeholder concerns to modify their behavior.

Responsiveness is not equal to adaptation. Organisations cannot comply with all the demands of their stakeholders. Expectations of stakeholders are often multiple, conflicting and inconsistent with other obligations and responsibilities. However, listening organizations should be able to articulate and demonstrate how stakeholders’ concerns were taken into account, why a particular decision was made and whether any changes will take place. Thus, responsiveness may manifest itself in the following ways: policy change, communication strategy modification, stakeholder engagement redesign, commitment clarifications, internal discussion and elaboration of reasons for decision-making.

In this sense, responsiveness creates a link between listening and organizational legitimacy. According to Suchman (1995), legitimacy is defined as a generalized perception that organisational actions are appropriate, desirable or proper in a given system of norms and expectations. Organizational listening contributes to legitimacy as it allows organizations to better understand stakeholder judgments of the appropriateness of the organisation’s actions. However, legitimacy does not arise because of listening per se. It arises because listening produces effects in the organization.

It is now clear that a relational view of listening involves consideration of the three dimensions discussed above: recognition, interpretation and responsiveness. Only when these dimensions come together, listening can contribute to organizational legitimacy.

 
Listening, Legitimacy, and Strategic Alignment

One of the advantages of such an approach to listening is that it helps better define the relationships between listening, legitimacy and strategic alignment. Legitimacy does not refer to an attribute permanently owned by the organisation, nor is it a state of affairs resulting from an evaluation. Legitimacy is rather a socially constructed condition depending on the degree of appropriateness of organisational behaviour according to a certain system of institutional values and expectations (Suchman, 1995). From this perspective, listening fosters legitimacy since it gives organisations a possibility to perceive how they are understood and accepted by stakeholders.

The relevance of such an understanding of listening is evident in current contexts where the assessment of organisations depends significantly on the coherence between their claims and conduct. Stakeholders may question discrepancies between the organisation’s stated purpose and managerial decisions, promises regarding sustainability and practices or commitment to inclusivity and the experience of inclusion in the organisation. Such tensions are neither mere communication challenges, but issues concerning the credibility of organisations as social actors. Listening allows organisations to identify such tensions early enough to prevent them from turning into criticisms or claims about legitimacy loss.

Finally, listening relates to strategic alignment in terms of coherence between identity, strategy, communication and stakeholder environment. Such coherence is never permanent or complete but must be constantly produced and maintained through interpretation and adjustment. The process of maintaining such coherence can be facilitated through stakeholder listening, because listening allows organisations to find out how their behaviour is perceived and where the discrepancies between intended positioning and stakeholder perception occur.

Nevertheless, it is essential to realise that listening’s value lies precisely in its potential to disrupt the status quo. Stakeholder views can contradict organisational assumptions, challenge dominant discourses or expose inconsistencies of which the organisation wants to stay unaware. This explains why listening cannot be treated as a passive practice. Listening means choosing to be vulnerable to other perspectives and willing to learn something new or unexpected. Listening that only confirms existing strategies can hardly be called listening. On the contrary, listening that exposes the organisation to uncomfortable knowledge paves the way to the development of a mature capability for relational governance.
 

Implications for Communication Professionals

As can be seen from the above analysis, the presented understanding of listening also entails some implications for the practice of communication professionals. First, the notion of listening presented above demonstrates clearly that public relations cannot be considered solely a practice related to the production and distribution of messages. Listening implies taking into account stakeholder expectations and using them as the basis for managing relationships and decision making.

Therefore, apart from knowing how to implement listening practices, communication professionals are expected to possess some competence in interpreting stakeholder perceptions. The task of a communication professional is to facilitate listening within organisations, which means identifying the concerns raised by stakeholders and bringing them into organisational discussion.
Second, communication professionals are expected to play a mediating role within the organisation. The information obtained during listening will become truly valuable only when it reaches the organisational arena where the organisation’s decisions are discussed. However, this is unlikely to happen when reports and metrics remain separated from managerial deliberations. Therefore, the communication function is supposed to facilitate the establishment of processes for sharing stakeholder perspectives and analysing their relevance for the organisation.

Third, communication professionals can assist the organisation in implementing responsiveness. Responding to stakeholder expectations does not imply adapting automatically to each external claim. Instead, responsiveness involves taking stakeholders’ demands seriously, considering them in relation to organisational duties and translating them into action. As a result of such responsiveness, a policy change, communication strategy revision, improvement of engagement practice, explanation of organisational commitments and clarification of managerial decisions may take place.
 

Conclusion

In summary, it can be concluded that listening should be considered an integral part of relational governance. Based on the relational approach to public relations elaborated by Toni Muzi Falconi, this paper has presented the view of listening as a capability that brings together stakeholder expectations, interpretation and decision making in organisations.

While focusing on the notion of listening, this article has highlighted the difference between a broad, relational approach to listening and the traditional, more narrow view of listening associated with feedback gathering and environmental scanning. Consequently, it has shown that listening becomes significant when organisations are able to discover stakeholders’ concerns, interpret them and assess their implications for the organisation’s conduct. In this case, the following three dimensions of listening can be distinguished: recognition of concerns, relational interpretation and responsiveness. Taken together, these three dimensions allow for distinguishing between symbolic listening and consequential listening.

The main theoretical contribution of this article consists in connecting the notion of listening to relational aspects of public relations. Listening is not an additional activity or a preliminary phase of communication. Instead, it is a practice allowing organisations to admit interdependence, interpret expectations and negotiate legitimacy in interaction with the stakeholder environment. Thus, listening contributes to the broader understanding of public relations as a managerial function focused on relationships and organisational accountability.

Practically, the suggested framework implies that listening requires certain organisational conditions. First, an organisation needs a proper methodology of listening to be able to identify stakeholders’ concerns. Next, it needs spaces for interpretation and discussion of stakeholder perspectives. Finally, communication professionals need to facilitate listening by ensuring that relevant insights reach different areas of organisational life. Without these conditions, listening is unlikely to have any consequences. Otherwise, it becomes a powerful tool for sustaining relationships and strengthening legitimacy.


References

Freeman, R. E. (1984). Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach. Pitman.

Grunig, J. E. (Ed.). (1992). Excellence in Public Relations and Communication Management. Lawrence Erlbaum.

Kent, M. L., & Taylor, M. (2002). Toward a dialogic theory of public relations. Public Relations Review, 28(1), 21–37.

Ledingham, J. A. (2003). Explicating relationship management as a general theory of public relations. Journal of Public Relations Research, 15(2), 181–198.

Ledingham, J. A., & Bruning, S. D. (1998). Relationship management in public relations: Dimensions of an organization public relationship. Public Relations Review, 24(1), 55–65.

Macnamara, J. (2016). Organizational Listening: The Missing Essential in Public Communication. Peter Lang.

Mitchell, R. K., Agle, B. R., & Wood, D. J. (1997). Toward a theory of stakeholder identification and salience: Defining the principle of who and what really counts. Academy of Management Review, 22(4), 853–886.

Muzi Falconi, T. (2006). How big is public relations (and why does it matter?). Institute for Public Relations.

Muzi Falconi, T. (2009). Global stakeholder relationship governance. Gainesville: Institute for Public Relations.

Muzi Falconi, T. (2014). Global stakeholder relationships governance: An infrastructure. In Global stakeholder relationships governance: An infrastructure (pp. 1-55). London: Palgrave Macmillan UK.

Suchman, M. C. (1995). Managing legitimacy: Strategic and institutional approaches. Academy of Management Review, 20(3), 571–610.

Weick, K. E. (1995). Sensemaking in Organizations. Sage.


List item
List item
List item

BACK TO THE CONTRIBUTOR’S LIST